Following some correspondence with Bob Shepherd on WikiTree I was struggling to understand how there could be two marriage records, within a year of each other, between James Mutch and Jane/Jessie Henry. Both showed the bride’s father was William Henry and her mother as either Catherine/Jean Bimblbe or Jane Dimlay and both James were cousins.

After checking the original records I found seperate birth records for Jessie Ann Henry and Jane Henry. Father William Henry is listed as a Ropemaker on both the birth and marriage records for Jane and Jessie. This, together with the similarity in mothers (very badly spelt) surname, led me to conclude that these two sisters married two cousin James Mutches within a year of each other.

Thanks to Bob Shepherd for pointing me in the right direction.